patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Franzen Declines Several Senate District 49 Debates

DFL candidate Melisa Franzen said her busy election schedule doesn't allow time for debates beyond the six forums she's already taken part in.

 

Senate District 49 candidate Melisa Franzen (DFL) has turned down at least five invitations for public debates, according to her Republican opponent.

Keith Downey (R-Edina) says Franzen declined five debates against him within the Senate district during this election season.

In an Oct. 17 letter to Franzen, Downey said he believes the residents of the district are interested in getting to know the candidates better. Downey said an actual debate would allow more "give and take and the chance for rebuttal" than candidate forums, arguing debates offer a "real way to educate voters on the merits of our respective positions."

"Please reconsider your opposition to full debates," he wrote. "In our positions, short term campaign tactics should always be subordinate to what is good for the people of our district."

Downey himself offered to host two debates, as did Edina Patch, the Edina Sun-Current and the Edina Rotary Club. Franzen declined all of those invitations.

A debate between the two candidates before the Rotary Club had actually been booked for Oct. 4, but Edina Rotary Public Relations Director Heather Hansen said it was later canceled because Franzen could no longer participate on that given day.

"The message I received was that Melisa Franzen had changed her mind and decided not to participate in the first Edina Rotary debate," Hansen said. 

In an email exchange with Patch, Frazen said she understands "why people might be confused" about her decision to not take part in the debates. Franzen said she had already committed to participating in six candidate forums throughout the district, which are "sponsored by groups with a strong tradition of holding substantive, informative discussions."

"Since I became a candidate in February of this year, I have received invitations to a tremendous number of public events, issue forums, meet-and-greet events, candidate forums and more," Franzen wrote. "While I would love to attend them all, it simply isn't possible." 

Franzen said she's had countless one-on-one conversations with members of the community at a variety of events and while door-knocking around the district. Through the six public forums Franzen has already participated in—that list is below—she said she's had plenty of chances to discuss a number of important issues. Downey was also present at a number of those forums.

Senate District 49 Forum Dates

  • 9/6/12—Bloomington Chamber of Commerce Candidate Forum—Bloomington, MN
  • 9/19/12—Normandale Community College & Minnesota State College Student Association Candidate Forum—Bloomington, MN
  • 9/19/12—I-35W Transportation Solutions Alliance Candiate Forum—Bloomington, MN
  • 10/1/12—Edina League of Women Voters Candidate Forum—Edina, MN
  • 10/8/12—Edina Parent Leadership Association Candidate Forum—Edina, MN
  • 10/9/12—Bloomington League of Women Voters Candidate Forum—Bloomington, MN

Like Edina Patch on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter | Sign up for our daily newsletter

Related Topics: Candidate Forums, Debates, Keith Downey, Melisa Franzen, Senate District 49, State Senate, and election 2012

David F

8:33 am on Friday, October 19, 2012

I think Franzen with a full time job did not realize how consuming running for political office can become. Politics can be an emotional and physically exhausting endevour.

Reply

Olaf M

9:40 am on Friday, October 19, 2012

Seems more sensational than actually newsworthy. Also, there must be more to the story. Regardless, there have been some really good discussions at the debates/forums that have already been held (like seven or more). Bonus is that some were recorded with content available online so people can view if they weren't able to attend. I've personally found Melisa to be very open and receptive to discussion.

Reply

John Cashmore

12:20 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

I think it is important to note that Melissa has a full-time job and family, plus running for office. Mr. Downey probably has no job, so maybe he has more time to run full-time.

Reply

Tom LaForce

1:59 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

This story needs more details. What are the specifics around these events? I noticed you don't mention that Keith is a member of the Rotary. That might be useful to know. Does it make sense for a candidate to accept an invitation to her opponent's club? You don't lay out the proposals associated with Patch and the Sun. What did you have in mind? What exactly was Keith proposing? But here's my main question, why is this newsworthy? These candidates have already participated in all the forums that typically take place in the district. Running a story like this plays into the GOP's messaging for this race. I hope it wasn't in response to the baiting from anonymous commenters on the first Kluwe story .

Reply

Angela Berger

2:17 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

Usually a first time candidate, seen as the challenger, takes any chance offered to speak to the public and especially to differentiate themselves from their opponent. Edina residents only had one forum that was advertised to the public, the League of Women Voters. Melisa did very well and was even helped by the moderator interrupting Downey's answer at one point. I can't imagine why she would not want more opportunities like that.

Only two forums in total were advertised to the public to attend. Three are available to view on videotape. All of the other ones either required a fee to attend or were specifically targeted to their memberships to attend. This is very strange that Franzen would turn down so many requests. Keith Downey has extended his offer more than once, even with "fake" debates being proposed against Mr. Downey by football players.

Reply

Scott Anderson

3:11 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

All six of these forums were advertised, Angela. What news sources do you look to?

Reply

Edinamom2

3:12 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

Melisa clearly does not want any venues that would require her to defend her positions. These "forums" do no allow for rebuttals or cross-questioning. Usually it's the incumbent that hides from debates so this is very curious. I have seen her live and she is very vague in her answers. Just DFL boilerplate. Downey clearly is very knowledgeable about the issues and she suffers in comparison.

Reply

Edinamom2

3:18 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

Hey Tom Laforce should Downey have avoided the two League of Women Voters events because he is not a woman? You are really stretching here! The Rotary is a very mainstream organization. Franzen backed out last minute. That is the fact. Your speculations are just spin.

Reply

Tom LaForce

3:26 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

Question for the moderator. Can the same person comment with two different handles on the same story? Just curious on the off chance it ever happens.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Ryan Gauthier

3:30 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

That's a good question, Tom. I haven't heard of it before, but I suppose it might be possible for a user to log in and comment, then log out and back in under a different username to post a different comment. I share the sentiment that it would be much better if folks would use their actual names on the site, but that's also a difficult thing to police.

Reply

Edinamom2

3:38 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

If Tom Laforce you are suggesting I am Angie Berger you are incorrect. There is more than one person who dares to disagree with you. Shocking I know. Funny as soon as you feel threatened you call for the moderator. When the facts are not on your side create a distraction...

Reply

Tom LaForce

3:54 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

Edinamom2, I prefer to interact with people who use their names. Patch started out with that requirement in their terms of use. I see they've since changed it to more of an encouragement. As for you being Angie, that's not what I asked.

Reply

Edinamom2

4:17 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

There are "binders full of women" who disagree with the Left. And I don't use my name because I don't like to be called a hater and all the other names thrown out at those that dare to disagree. Moments ago Scott Anderson just called anyone who votes "Yes" on the marriage amendment a bigot on another Patch comment thread. This type of bullying is what forces people to remain anonymous. Tom it appears you want to control the comments here. Remember you are not the moderator on this site. Save your bullying for your little Facebook forum.

Reply

Tom LaForce

4:23 pm on Friday, October 19, 2012

I see what you mean about being attacked when you use your name.

Reply

Leave a comment